One of the most important steps in evaluating an investment property happens before you ever make an offer: understanding what the property is actually worth.
For real estate investors, comparable sales (commonly called comps) are one of the most valuable tools for determining a property’s potential After Repair Value (ARV). Getting this number wrong can mean the difference between a profitable project and a deal that becomes difficult to exit.
In today’s real estate market, where properties in some areas are taking longer to sell, accurate comps and realistic expectations matter more than ever.
Here are a few things every investor should consider when evaluating comparable properties.
1. Focus on SOLD Properties, Not Just Active Listings
It’s easy to get caught up in what other sellers are asking for their properties. But an asking price doesn’t necessarily reflect what a buyer is willing to pay.
Active listings and pending sales can provide helpful insight into your competition, but closed sales offer the strongest evidence of actual market value.
When evaluating comps, pay close attention to what similar properties have recently sold for rather than relying on optimistic listing prices.
2. Prioritize Recent Sales
Real estate markets can change quickly. A comparable property that sold six or twelve months ago may not accurately reflect current market conditions.
Whenever possible, prioritize comparable sales from the last 90 days. If there aren’t enough relevant sales within that timeframe, expand your search while considering how market conditions may have changed.
Pay attention to:
- Recent shifts in buyer demand
- Changes in inventory and competition
- Longer days on market
- Price reductions before closing
- Seasonal trends in your local market
The goal is to understand what buyers are paying today, not what a similar property might have sold for in a different market.
3. Compare Apples to Apples
Not all properties in the same neighborhood are truly comparable.
A property just a few streets away can have a significantly different value depending on its location, condition, size and features.
When selecting comps, consider:
- Location: Prioritize the same neighborhood or immediate surrounding area whenever possible.
- Square footage: Look for properties with similar living areas.
- Bedrooms and bathrooms: These can have a meaningful impact on buyer demand and value.
- Lot size: Larger or more desirable lots may command a premium.
- Age and construction: Consider the property’s age, layout and overall construction.
- Condition and finishes: Compare renovated properties with similar levels of renovation and quality.
A good comp should resemble the property you’re evaluating as closely as possible.
4. Be Conservative When Calculating ARV
After Repair Value is an estimate of what a property could sell for once renovations are complete.
It’s tempting to build your numbers around the highest comparable sale, especially when you’re excited about a potential project. But using the most optimistic valuation can leave very little room for error.
Instead, look at the range of comparable sales and determine where your property realistically fits.
Consider whether your planned renovations will truly support the projected value. High-end finishes don’t always translate into a dollar-for-dollar increase in resale value.
A conservative ARV gives you a more realistic starting point when calculating your maximum purchase price and potential profit.
5. Factor in Days on Market and Your Exit Strategy
One factor investors sometimes overlook is how long comparable properties took to sell.
A property that eventually sold for a strong price may have spent several months on the market before finding a buyer. That matters.
Longer market times can mean additional interest, insurance, taxes, utilities and other carrying costs. They can also put pressure on an investor who needs to refinance, sell or move on to the next project.
When reviewing comps, look beyond the final sales price. Consider:
- How long the property was listed
- Whether the seller reduced the asking price
- Whether the property went under contract and returned to market
- How much competition exists in the area
Run your numbers with a longer-than-expected holding period and consider what happens if you need to accept a lower sale price than anticipated.
A deal that only works if everything goes perfectly may deserve a second look.
6. Remember: The Best Deals Start With the Right Purchase Price
Ultimately, comps aren’t just about determining what a property might be worth after renovations. They’re about helping you make a smarter buying decision.
Your purchase price, renovation budget, financing costs, holding expenses and expected resale value all work together. If one assumption is too optimistic, it can impact the entire project.
The strongest investors take the time to understand their market, evaluate their numbers and leave room for unexpected costs or delays.
The goal isn’t to find comps that justify your purchase price. It’s to understand what the market is actually telling you.
Financing Your Next Investment
At Low Tide Private Lending, we understand that every investment project comes with its own opportunities and challenges. We work with real estate investors on fix-and-flip projects, bridge financing, cash-out refinances and other short-term residential investment financing needs.
As a relationship-focused private lender, we believe in straightforward communication, thoughtful underwriting and working directly with our borrowers to understand their projects.
Whether you’re evaluating your next acquisition or planning your next renovation, having realistic numbers is an important first step.
Do your homework before you buy. A profitable exit starts with a realistic entry.
Learn more about our financing options at LowTideLending.com.